This was going to be a “Dear LazyWeb” request, but after some research I found what I wanted.
Recent discussions about security and phishing on the OpenID list got me thinking about the problem space.
DNS plays a critical role in the security of OpenID because
- URL is the identifier type used
- User should only trust the OP with which he/she has an account with.
The “Phishing and OpenID” discussions on the OpenID list actually hinges on point #2 above. Ben Laurie wrote about it here. In short, OpenID opens the door for a malicious RP to send a user to a spoofed OP-lookalike and collect his/her password.
Back to DNS. I have, on numerous occasions in the past, tried to look for a list of domains where registrations are open for public. This varies from TLD to TLD, e.g. .biz accepts registration directly on the second level, .us also does but delegates two-letter subdomains to US states, and .uk only accepts registrations on the third level after .co.uk, .ac.uk, etc.
So, this advisory started this bugzilla entry at Mozilla and it eventually led to the creation of this API and this list (see attachment). They call it the “Effective TLD” list, which is really a misnomer because they are not necessary just TLDs. It was decided in the bug discussions that the term “effective TLD” is easier to digest that anything else, though I’d prefer to call it “Security Restricted Domains”. Whatever, as long as it gives me the content I want.
Many will probably criticize Mozilla for creating yet another list that gets stale the moment it is created. Indeed, TLDs get created and 2LDs within TLDs are introduced and deprecated so often that such a list will be hard to maintain. Moreover, many organizations assign names to registrants at a level that doesn’t involve the TLD registry. Examples include CentralNIC’s .<country-code>.com and *.blogspot.com, and countless others. Add to it the introduction of IDN TLD may well be in less than 2 years. Keeping a definitive list is not feasible. Nevertheless, I would argue that depending on your needs, this list could still be very valuable, as is the case with the cookie problem that they are trying to solve.
So, what has this got to do with OpenID? I shall leave that to a different post.
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.